Skip to main content

Creating and Comparing Tax Scenarios

Written by Taylor Stewart

Use Planning → Taxes → Scenarios to save alternative tax assumptions, then Compare to see how their calculated results differ. Taxes is labeled Beta.

For unchanged Compare results, fixed QBI amounts, or combined 401(k), profit-sharing, and cash-balance-plan limits, see Why Do Taxes Paid or Projected Taxes Look Unexpected?

Copy a reviewed baseline before testing a strategy. Scenario edits don't execute contributions, conversions, payments, or filings.

How do I create a tax scenario?

On Planning → Taxes → Scenarios, advisors use the plus menu in the scenario bar to create another scenario.

  1. Open Scenarios and select +, whose tooltip is New scenario.

  2. Choose Manual input to start with default and derived values.

  3. Enter New Calculator Name, such as “2026 Baseline,” and select Confirm.

  4. Open the new scenario's Inputs and confirm Tax Year, State, and Filing Status before reviewing its figures.

The plus menu also offers Copy this scenario and completed returns under From a tax return. Importing a Client's Tax Return explains the return route and household-name matching.

New households normally start with Current Tax Scenario. If Scenarios returns to Overview without a scenario bar, open Returns and select a completed return with extracted fields, then Create scenario.

Importing a Client’s Tax Return covers starting an import if needed. Contact Support if you need manual creation without a usable return; empty Overview has no Manual input control.

How do I preserve a tax scenario baseline and test an alternative?

On Planning → Taxes → Scenarios, Copy this scenario creates a separate saved scenario with the original's input settings.

  1. Select the baseline scenario and check its year and source amounts.

  2. Select + → Copy this scenario.

  3. Enter a name in Copy Calculator, such as “2026 Roth conversion,” and select Confirm.

  4. Change only the intended assumptions in the copy's Inputs.

  5. Read Analysis, then open Compare. Compare uses the scenario you were viewing as its baseline. Select Add scenario if the original isn't displayed, then open that original's ⋮ menu and select Make baseline to compare the copy against it.

Copying preserves derived fields as derived fields. Both scenarios can therefore change when their shared Profile sources change; a copy isn't a frozen record of calculated results. Imported and manual overrides remain fixed until edited or returned to derived mode.

The Overview opportunity queue is unavailable, so use this saved-scenario workflow for alternatives. Tax Overview: Reviewing a Client's Tax Position explains that screen.

How do I rename or delete a tax scenario?

On Planning → Taxes → Scenarios, choose a scenario in the picker, open the ⋮ menu with the tooltip Scenario actions, and select Rename. Enter the new name in the Rename scenario dialog and select Confirm.

To delete a scenario:

  1. Choose the scenario you intend to remove in the scenario picker.

  2. Open Scenario actions and select Delete scenario.

  3. Select Delete in the Delete this scenario? confirmation.

Delete scenario is disabled when only one scenario remains, with the explanation “A client keeps at least one scenario.” There isn't a restore control in this workflow. Preserve any result needed for your planning records before deletion.

If the scenario is main, select another scenario and choose Set as main before deletion. Deleting main leaves household taxes, including Cash flow taxes, at $0 until another scenario is set as main.

If you already deleted it, choose a remaining scenario in the picker and select Set as main, then check Cash flow. Check Guides that use a specific scenario too: removing their selected scenario can leave the tax component without results. Removing a Compare column is different; it doesn't delete its saved scenario.

How do I choose the main tax scenario?

In Planning → Taxes → Scenarios, Set as main makes the selected scenario that scenario's household tax source where a view follows its main scenario.

  1. Choose the intended scenario in the scenario picker.

  2. Select Set as main if it appears. This button is available from each scenario view.

  3. Confirm the main-scenario badge on the selected name and the Main scenario text in the picker, then review affected household tax figures.

This saves a household selection immediately. It can replace a manually entered household tax amount as the active source; it doesn't rewrite Profile income or savings records.

Overview initially follows this selection, and Guide tax components can follow it too. A Guide configured for a specific scenario keeps its own selection. Choosing Make baseline inside Compare only changes the comparison baseline; it doesn't set the household's main scenario.

What do the views inside a tax scenario show?

In Planning → Taxes → Scenarios, each selected scenario offers Inputs, Analysis, Client report, and 1040 review.

  • Inputs holds configuration, income, adjustments, deductions, credits, and payments.

  • Analysis explains calculated results and planning relationships.

  • Client report presents an explanation of that scenario for review and delivery.

  • 1040 review organizes supported modeled values by return line. It doesn't reproduce or file the source PDF.

Advisors, including firm owners, should use Inputs, Analysis, and 1040 review for source checks. Firm ownership doesn't grant access to the internal Reconciliation view.

Overview, Scenarios, Compare, and Returns are the Taxes pages. Returns holds extracted source forms; a scenario holds inputs and calculated results. For detailed result interpretation, see Tax Analysis: Reading a Tax Scenario's Results.

In a scenario's Inputs, one button closes or opens every input section without changing values. It reads Collapse all while any section is open and Expand all once all are closed.

How do derived inputs and manual overrides work in a tax scenario?

In a scenario's Inputs, derived values follow saved household records, while manual overrides apply to that scenario. Edits save as fields change; there isn't a final Save button for the whole scenario.

  1. Select the intended scenario and Tax Year.

  2. Find the amount and inspect its source explanation. For a derived numeric field, use its pencil icon to enter a custom value.

  3. Enter the annual amount for that field and review the recalculated result.

  4. Use the circular-arrow icon to discard that override and return to the calculated source value.

Wages, self-employment income, and Social Security derive from Clients' income records active in the scenario's tax year. An Other adult's per-person records don't feed a scenario. Changing a year doesn't replace fixed imported or manually entered amounts.

Correct Profile when a shared source fact is wrong. Use a scenario override when testing a different assumption. Client Settings: Notes, Objective, Tax State, and Filing Status covers household-default entry; Why Do Taxes Paid or Projected Taxes Look Unexpected? covers wage reconciliation.

Do tax scenarios include taxes for my client's business, such as an S corporation?

Planning → Taxes estimates a household's taxes, including entered S-corp pass-through income and shareholder wages. It doesn't prepare a separate S-corporation return or calculate a company's full tax obligations. Recording a Business or its valuation doesn't automatically supply S-corp pass-through income to a tax scenario.

  1. Copy a reviewed scenario and confirm its Tax Year.

  2. In Inputs → Income, select the table icon (Open worksheet) beside Additional income. Under Schedule E income, enter verified S-corp pass-through income for the appropriate Client.

  3. Enter shareholder W-2 wages in the Wage income worksheet, separately from pass-through income.

  4. In Inputs → Other deductions, select Open worksheet beside Qualified business income deduction. In QBI activities, confirm that Current-year QBI includes the Client's S-corp income. Saved activity amounts don't update with income changes; then compare this scenario with your baseline.

The S-corp pass-through field contributes to modeled household income but isn't included in the self-employment-tax base. Schedule C net profit/loss and Partnership SE earnings have separate fields; don't use them interchangeably with S-corp income.

Only Clients have per-person tax inputs. Other adults' stored income inputs and business activities are skipped. Confirm classifications and amounts with your client's tax professional; scenario fields don't establish eligibility or replace a business return.

How do I enter QBI activity facts in a tax scenario?

In Planning → Taxes → Scenarios, QBI activities supply facts for the modeled qualified business income deduction. Adding a QBI activity doesn't add pass-through income to the scenario's income total; enter income separately in Inputs → Income.

  1. In Inputs → Other deductions, find Qualified business income deduction (line 13a) and select its table icon (Open worksheet).

  2. In QBI activities, select Add QBI activity if a new activity is needed.

  3. Check Activity, Owner, Type, Current-year QBI, QBI loss carryforward, W-2 wages paid, Qualified property (UBIA), and SSTB against your source records.

  4. Check Include in QBI calculation and review QBI calculation after editing. Changes save as fields change.

W-2 wages paid means business wages for QBI limits, not a Client's personal wages. UBIA records qualified-property basis for that limitation; SSTB records specified service trade or business status. Kerdora simplifies QBI calculations and doesn't establish those facts.

Adding or editing any activity fixes every listed Current-year QBI amount. Update those amounts after business-income changes; see Why Do Taxes Paid or Projected Taxes Look Unexpected?

Activities owned by an Other adult are hidden and excluded, but kept through edits. Changing that person back to Client makes the saved activities available again. Don't add duplicate activities just because the owner's member type changed.

Is there a report showing an existing tax scenario versus an optimized one?

Planning → Taxes → Compare shows differences between saved scenarios on screen. Use a reviewed baseline and a copy with only the intended changes.

  1. Select the reviewed scenario in Scenarios, then open Compare and check which column is marked Baseline. Compare has no scenario picker.

  2. Select Add scenario to include the proposed alternative if it isn't already displayed.

  3. To change the baseline, open an alternative column's ⋮ menu and select Make baseline. The old baseline takes that alternative's column.

  4. Turn on Only lines that differ to focus on differing outputs. Use Show change vs baseline to hide or show the line-item differences. The Total Tax comparison remains visible.

Compare supports 1 baseline plus up to 4 alternatives, for 5 scenario columns total. With only 1 saved scenario, Duplicate current scenario creates a copy for comparison; edit that copy before expecting different results.

The generated tax-report PDF describes a selected scenario, not this side-by-side comparison table. For client delivery, explain the difference in a Guide or provide reviewed reports for both scenarios.

How do I change or remove tax scenario comparison columns?

On Planning → Taxes → Compare, open an alternative column's ⋮ menu and select Remove from comparison to remove it. Select Add scenario to include another saved scenario.

Remove from comparison is available when more than 1 alternative is displayed. Compare keeps a baseline and at least 1 alternative. These controls change the comparison only; they don't delete or edit saved scenarios.

A scenario already displayed isn't available as another added column. Add scenario is disabled at 5 total columns, with “Up to 5 scenarios fit in one comparison.” If no unused scenario remains, it shows “Every scenario is already in the comparison.”

Add another alternative before removing the only alternative.

The comparison's scenario choices and Only lines that differ / Show change vs baseline settings are recorded in its page address. Bookmark that address to revisit the same setup. It still reads current saved scenario values and isn't a frozen report or a client-delivery link.

What should I read in the tax scenario comparison table?

On Planning → Taxes → Compare, each alternative's delta is its output minus the baseline's output. An arrow shows whether the result increased or decreased, with an unsigned amount; rate changes use percentage points (pts). Read the row meaning before interpreting the color.

Start with the Total Tax row, which stays pinned with the scenario names while the page scrolls when the table fits the page. It shows Same as baseline when unchanged.

Then review relevant groups: Income, Tax Breakdown, Rates, Deductions & Credits, Planning Room, and Payments when present. Planning Room includes the modeled Roth Conversion, Ordinary Bracket Room, and 0% LTCG Room.

Those figures aren't a recommendation to use every available dollar. Groups start expanded; select a group heading to collapse it.

Payments appears when the baseline or first alternative has payments. Put a scenario with payments in one of those positions if payment rows are missing from a larger comparison.

Linked row labels open an input location in the baseline scenario. They don't edit an alternative, and a linked field isn't necessarily the sole cause of that output. Open the intended scenario's Inputs directly before correcting an alternative.

Can tax planning scenarios be exported as PDF?

Yes. In Planning → Taxes → Scenarios, an advisor can generate a PDF for the selected scenario.

  1. Choose the reviewed scenario in the picker and open Client report.

  2. Select Print PDF and wait for generation.

  3. Review the PDF in Kerdora's full-screen preview. Select Download to save a copy, Open in new tab to view it in your browser, or Save to Documents to keep it on this client's Documents page.

For advisor-oriented output, Analysis → Print analysis uses the analysis report instead. Check scenario name, year, assumptions, and report contents before sharing. Neither action exports the Compare table or sends a message to the client.

Clients can read tax results in visible Guides; standard client navigation doesn't list the Taxes workspace. Guide tax components may follow a main or specific scenario, so check their source before delivery. See Printing and Exporting Reports as PDF and Delivering a Guide to a Client for those broader workflows.

What should I do after choosing a tax scenario strategy?

In Planning → Taxes → Scenarios, review the selected alternative against verified source data before turning it into a recommendation.

Confirm year, filing status, state, income ownership, deductions, credits, payments, and any manual overrides. Check relevant limits: Kerdora provides planning estimates and uses simplified coverage for areas such as AMT, state taxes, QBI, and charitable contributions. It doesn't validate every eligibility rule or prepare a return.

Coordinate material tax treatment with your client's tax professional. Changes: Add, Review, and Share Recommendations covers recording an adopted recommendation; Tasks: Create, Assign, and Track Client Work covers implementation follow-up.

Review client-facing wording separately from exploratory calculations. Keep a record of the assumptions behind any report you deliver, particularly when derived values can change with household updates.

Did this answer your question?