Skip to main content

Why Do Taxes Paid or Projected Taxes Look Unexpected?

Written by Taylor Stewart

Why do taxes paid in Kerdora differ from actual taxes paid?

On Planning → Taxes, first identify which scenario figure you are comparing with a payment record. A household's tax scenario liability, its payment inputs, and its cash-flow tax assumption describe different things.

In Planning → Taxes → Scenarios, Total tax, labeled Modeled tax burden in the Inputs Live summary, includes modeled federal, state, payroll, and other included taxes. Withholding and estimated payments don't reduce that liability.

They affect the return balance and refund calculations instead. Federal return tax is before refundable credits and payments. Total tax adds state and regular payroll taxes and accounts for refundable credits.

In Analysis, Amount due shows federal return tax before payments; it isn’t the return’s balance due.

An amount paid with a filed return may be only the remaining balance after withholding and estimates. Comparing that check with the scenario's Total tax won't reconcile the two amounts.

For a cash-flow Taxes figure, check whether the household uses a selected tax scenario or a custom annual amount. That figure is an assumption used in household cash flow; it isn't a record of tax payments imported from a bank account.

What should I check before changing a tax scenario result?

In Planning → Taxes → Scenarios, select a scenario showing an unexpected result and confirm its inputs. Changing a different scenario won't correct the one being reviewed.

  1. Choose the scenario in the scenario picker and open Inputs.

  2. Check Tax Year, State, and Filing Status. A scenario can override its household's defaults.

  3. Compare income, deductions, credits, and payments with the source documents for that year.

  4. Identify manually entered values and values calculated from Profile. A manual override stops following its source until calculated behavior is restored.

  5. Open Analysis and its Details sections to inspect the relevant calculation.

For household settings, see Client Settings: Notes, Objective, Tax State, and Filing Status. For the pencil and restore controls, see Understanding Calculated and Manually Entered Values.

Preserve a verified baseline before testing changes. Creating and Comparing Tax Scenarios covers the copy-and-compare procedure; use its Only lines that differ toggle to isolate output differences without replacing the original assumptions.

Where do I enter withholding or estimated payments in a tax scenario?

Enter payment amounts in the selected tax scenario's Inputs → Payments. These entries change payment and balance calculations, not the scenario's income or calculated tax liability.

  1. Expand Payments if collapsed. Its Withholding & payments subsection starts expanded.

  2. Under Federal withholding, enter the amounts in W-2, 1099, and Other as appropriate.

  3. Enter State withholding separately.

  4. Enter federal estimated payments in the Q1, Q2, Q3, and Q4 fields under Estimated payments.

  5. Check Prior-year overpayment, Apply overpayment to next year, and Estimated tax penalty against the source return or payment records.

These are dollar totals for the scenario year or the named quarter, not monthly amounts with a frequency selector. Use consistent full-year assumptions when estimating a full-year result; a year-to-date withholding total may leave later payroll withholding unrepresented.

If an older scenario shows Existing unsplit estimated payments, entering quarterly payments replaces that saved total rather than adding to it. Enter all applicable quarters when replacing the unsplit amount.

The Q1–Q4 fields are federal only. There’s no state estimated-payment field; the state balance subtracts only State withholding, so it doesn’t reflect state estimates already paid. Reconcile those payments separately.

Why does a tax scenario refund or balance due still look wrong?

In a tax scenario, the federal balance calculation compares federal return tax with federal withholding, federal estimates, prior-year overpayment applied, and refundable credits. An entered estimated-tax penalty increases the balance. An amount applied to next year can reduce the refund available now.

The state balance uses modeled state tax less state withholding. The combined return balance brings the federal and state balances together. This is why subtracting a payment total from Total tax doesn't necessarily reproduce the displayed return balance: Total tax also includes regular payroll taxes, while the return calculations have their own credit and payment treatment.

Review the payment fields and the relevant return lines in 1040 review before changing income to force a match. An imported total can also differ from the source document if extraction or field mapping was incomplete; see Importing a Client's Tax Return.

A safe-harbor payment target answers a separate question from the return balance. See Tax Analysis: Reading a Tax Scenario's Results for its calculation and limits.

Should I remove 401(k) contributions when tax scenario wages are already net of deferrals?

Keep accurate savings in Profile. In a tax scenario you're reviewing, first check whether Wage income, the Form 1040 line 1a amount, is overridden or calculated from the Wage worksheet.

  1. Open the scenario's Inputs and find Wage income in Income.

  2. Use the table icon with the Open worksheet tooltip to inspect the Wage worksheet.

  3. Check for the message that the 1040 line 1a override is active. In that case, the scenario uses the household wage total and skips another subtraction for retirement deferrals. The individual wage rows don't feed that overridden total.

  4. If the worksheet is active, check Salary / regular wages and Pre-tax Retirement Deferrals for each person. A salary amount already reduced by deferrals needs review before another deferral subtraction is applied.

A direct Wage income override puts all wages on that household's first Client, zeros the other filers' wages, and ignores everyone’s deferrals and payroll deductions for calculation. For 2 earners or wages already net of deferrals, Social Security and Medicare taxes can differ from the W-2s. Use the worksheet with verified per-person wages and deductions when payroll-tax results matter; restore calculated Wage income first.

Enter Retirement Savings, Employer Match, and Contribution Limits explains the Profile contribution entry. Removing real savings to correct a tax input can understate that household's planned savings.

Where does employer match show up in the tax calculation?

In Planning → Taxes, a tax scenario's derived Pre-tax Retirement Deferrals uses each Client's supported employee account savings. It doesn't add the separate employer-match amount to that Client's deferral deduction or treat that match as household wages.

Don’t add employer match to Wage income and then enter an offsetting deduction to make the result agree. The separate employer-match setting serves account and Goal funding, while the wage worksheet is determining the taxable wage amount from the inputs it supports.

See Enter Retirement Savings, Employer Match, and Contribution Limits for how to enter and review the match on the account. For profit sharing or cash balance arrangements, scenario fields don't establish a combined employer-plan contribution maximum. Review those limits with your client's tax professional before entering a deduction.

Where can I manually set a cash-flow tax amount?

For a fixed household cash-flow tax assumption, use Custom Amount from the Taxes menu in a Guide's Where is my income going? component. This changes the household tax amount; it doesn't override a tax scenario's calculated liability or enter payments on a return.

  1. Open a client Guide containing Where is my income going? with its Taxes field visible.

  2. Click Taxes, then Custom Amount.

  3. Enter Annual Tax Amount, even if the Guide is displaying monthly values.

  4. Click Submit and confirm the displayed Taxes amount.

The custom amount is shared household data, not a separate value saved only in that Guide. To resume using a scenario, choose it from the same Taxes menu or use Set as main in that scenario's bar from any scenario view. Changing the household source doesn't delete the tax scenarios you previously modeled.

Custom Amount currently appears only when at least one active tax scenario exists. If the component or Taxes field is absent, see Guide Components: Content, Filters, and Scope. For entering actual withholding or estimates, use the Payments fields instead.

Why does tax scenario income differ from Profile or a source return?

A tax scenario can combine Profile-derived inputs with imported or manually entered amounts. Start with the income category that differs rather than adding an offsetting deduction.

For Profile-derived wages, self-employment income, and Social Security, the scenario's tax year determines which income records are active. Check the recipient, amount, frequency, and start/end timing in the source record. See Cash Flow: Income, Savings, Spending, Debt Payments, and Giving for that procedure.

In the Wage worksheet, salary, bonus, RSUs, NQSOs, and deferred compensation are separate components. If a salary figure already includes one of those components, entering it again can overstate wages. Conversely, with the household Wage income override active, editing those component rows doesn't change the total used.

Check capital gains separately from wage compensation and sale proceeds. The scenario uses entered gain and loss amounts; an investment account's market value is not a realized gain. A tax-return import also needs review against the original forms before it becomes a trusted baseline.

Why is an Other adult's income missing from a tax scenario?

Planning → Taxes builds per-person tax inputs only for Clients. An Other adult's wages, self-employment income, Social Security, retirement deferrals, IRA and HSA contributions, student loan interest, and QBI business activities don't feed this household's tax scenario. Their age doesn't count toward its 65-or-older standard deduction either.

Changing a person from Client to Other adult can therefore lower scenario taxes without removing that person's income records from Profile.

Check Profile → Household for Member type, then inspect per-person inputs in Planning → Taxes → Scenarios. Saved per-person overrides and business activities for an Other adult are kept but skipped. Their business activities are also hidden from QBI activities, a worksheet opened from Inputs → Other deductions → Qualified business income deduction; changing that person back to Client makes those saved activities available again.

Household cash flow still includes active income belonging to Other adults. If cash flow uses this tax scenario, its income and tax figures can therefore cover different people. Review who belongs in this household's plan before changing types or using a custom cash-flow tax amount.

See Managing Household Members, Businesses, and Trusts.

Why can retirement taxes differ from a tax scenario for an Other adult?

A Retirement goal uses its own year-by-year tax calculation, while Planning → Taxes excludes an Other adult's per-person inputs from a tax scenario. Don't assume that making someone an Other adult removes their income from retirement calculations.

Retirement can still include that person's income lines. Projected wages and self-employment income are classified by income type and included in the retirement tax calculation, without using the tax scenario's Client-only person filter.

Compare the person's income timing and type in Profile → Cash flow, the Retirement goal's income results, and the selected tax scenario's Inputs. Different person coverage is expected.

After checking timing and overrides, contact Kerdora Support if a Client's active income is unexpectedly missing from a tax scenario, or an Other adult's active income is unexpectedly missing from a Retirement goal. Include household name, member type, income source, year, and amounts. A manual household cash-flow tax amount doesn't make these separate calculations use identical assumptions.

Why doesn't Gross income in a tax scenario include a pension rollover?

In Planning → Taxes, Gross income and Estimated gross income don't automatically include Form 1040 pension and annuity line 5a minus line 5b. A rollover can make that difference large without adding income available to spend, so entering a large gross pension distribution doesn't add that difference to Kerdora's gross-income summary.

Kerdora's Gross income starts with total income used in its tax calculation: wages after pre-tax payroll deductions and retirement deferrals, with only taxable Social Security. It adds back retirement deferrals, payroll deductions, and nontaxable Social Security, plus QCDs, tax-exempt interest, and entered Tax-Free Retirement Income. It isn't adjusted gross income or taxable income.

If a distribution includes nontaxable cash actually available to your client, review that cash separately from any rollover.

In a scenario's Inputs → Income, select the table icon (Open worksheet) beside IRA distributions. Expand IRA planning assumptions and enter that cash in Tax-Free Retirement Income. This field adds to modeled gross income without adding taxable income.

Don’t enter a transfer between retirement accounts as spendable income merely to reproduce line 5a.

Why does taxable Social Security in a tax scenario look unexpected?

In a tax scenario, a benefit's gross amount and its taxable portion are different figures. Check the Social Security source amount and scenario year before assuming an income reduction means a benefit is missing. A manually entered scenario amount may differ from Profile; see Entering Social Security in Kerdora for the source-entry checks.

The taxable portion depends on the scenario’s other income, so compare the benefit input separately from its taxable result. In the scenario’s Analysis, select Social Security in the Details section navigation when available.

Why does a charitable deduction in a tax scenario look unexpected?

In a tax scenario, check the Cash gifts amount and any override before changing Profile Giving. Profile Giving records marked Tax deductible can supply that amount even when Giving is turned off for that scenario's household. Giving: Tracking Charitable Contributions explains the checkbox and visibility behavior.

The charitable fields don't establish eligibility or fully calculate every gift-category limit and carryforward. Review the scenario's deduction method and Assumptions & limitations before treating an entered gift as an equal reduction in taxable income. Correct the source or intended tax input rather than an unrelated filing-status or deduction field.

What if verified tax scenario inputs still don't reproduce a filed return?

Kerdora's Taxes calculator supports planning estimates, with simplified treatment in areas including AMT, QBI, charitable deductions, and state income tax. It isn't a tax-return preparation or filing workflow, and a successful import doesn't establish that the calculated result matches the filed return.

Review Assumptions & limitations in Analysis. Confirm a complex return position, basis amount, election, or unsupported calculation with your client's tax professional before using an adjustment to represent it.

For a repeatable unexplained difference, contact Kerdora Support with the household, scenario name, tax year, exact screen and line, expected amount, displayed amount, and the source of the input. Include the smallest example that reproduces the discrepancy and whether the field is imported, calculated, or manually entered. Getting Help and Contacting Kerdora Support covers the support workflow.

How do I model a maxed-out 401(k), profit sharing, and a $100K cash balance contribution in a tax scenario?

In Planning → Taxes → Scenarios, you can test verified wage and deduction amounts, but Kerdora doesn't provide a combined 401(k), profit-sharing, and cash-balance-plan maximum calculator.

  1. Copy a reviewed baseline and confirm its Tax Year.

  2. In Inputs → Income, review Wage income and select its table icon, Open worksheet, before changing Pre-tax Retirement Deferrals. A direct Wage income override bypasses the worksheet's deferral subtraction.

  3. In Adjustments to income, review Self-employed SEP, SIMPLE, and qualified plans. Its Open worksheet icon provides per-person Self-employed plan contributions; the main line also accepts an override.

  4. Review the deduction actually used and compare results with the baseline.

That self-employed deduction is capped at 20% of modeled net self-employment earnings after the deductible part of self-employment tax. Even a direct override can be reduced. Typing $100,000 doesn't establish that the whole contribution is modeled or deductible.

There is no dedicated cash-balance input or automatic coordination of those plan limits. Don't put an employer contribution into employee deferrals or Other adjustments just to force a desired result. Verify the correct treatment and amount with your client's tax professional, and keep unsupported details outside the calculation.

Enter Retirement Savings, Employer Match, and Contribution Limits covers Profile contribution entry. Which scenario representation fits depends on your planning approach and your client's verified plan facts.

Why does tax scenario Compare say “No output differences between these scenarios”?

On Planning → Taxes → Compare, this message means no detail rows remain after filtering. Total Tax stays visible separately, so check its comparison even when this message appears.

Turn off Only lines that differ to show all output rows, then check that you edited the intended scenario. A new copy initially uses the same assumptions, so matching results are expected until an effective input changes.

If an edited amount still has no effect, inspect manual overrides and deduction or credit limits. For example, changing a Wage worksheet deferral won't change a direct Wage income override. Compare filters outputs; it doesn't prove every input matches or every detail of a tax return is covered.

Check the selected scenario's Inputs before changing unrelated Profile records. Creating and Comparing Tax Scenarios explains comparison controls.

Why doesn't a tax scenario's QBI deduction follow changed business income?

In Planning → Taxes → Scenarios, adding or editing a QBI activity saves fixed Current-year QBI amounts for every listed activity. Even renaming a Derived activity stops its amount from following later business-income changes.

Before activities are saved, QBI activities can show a Derived row for each Client with business income or saved QBI facts. Current-year QBI normally follows that Client's Schedule C, S-corp, and partnership income, unless an existing QBI override supplies it.

After changing business income:

  1. Open that scenario's Inputs → Other deductions.

  2. Select the table icon (Open worksheet) beside Qualified business income deduction (line 13a).

  3. In QBI activities, review every saved Current-year QBI amount against current business records and update amounts that should change.

  4. Review QBI calculation after editing. Changes save as fields change.

QBI activity edits affect deduction facts; they don't enter income. Keep source income in Inputs → Income consistent with your reviewed activity facts. Creating and Comparing Tax Scenarios covers S-corp entry and other activity fields.

Did this answer your question?